Over 360 employees facilitating the ideal shopping experience

Tarrytown Jewelers

Trusted Seller since 2010
This dealer owns a store in which you may view their watches.
Number of recommendations from other Chrono24 dealers: 1
Watches sold with Buyer Protection: 988

4.9 out of 5 stars  |  Reviews: 700

Detailed explanation of ratings 

 4.9
Shipping
 4.8
Item description
 4.9
Communication
98% of buyers would recommend this dealer.

Here's what buyers are saying about this dealer

Review by Jeff from on 25. May 2022


Tudor Tudor Black Bay 58

Buyer recommends this dealer

Shipping
Item description
Communication

Buyer's comment:

Great communication, fast shipping, love the watch. Would purchase from again.

Dealer's comment:

Thanks for the positive feedback. Pleasure to work with you.

Order canceled

Review by Adam D. from on 24. May 2022


Patek Philippe Patek Philippe Calatrava 5196R-001

Buyer recommends this dealer

Communication

Buyer's comment:

Great experience, highly recommend

Review by John H. from on 23. May 2022


Patek Philippe Patek Philippe Perpetual Calendar 5320G

Buyer recommends this dealer

Shipping
Item description
Communication

Buyer's comment:

-

Review by Lureen S. from on 23. May 2022


Patek Philippe Patek Philippe Cortina Jubilee 5057R-001

Buyer recommends this dealer

Shipping
Item description
Communication

Buyer's comment:

Prompt response and fast in shipping out.

Dealer's comment:

Exceptional transaction. Great communication from the buyer. Fast payment A+++. Enjoy the watch and wear in good health.

Review by Mike M. from on 21. May 2022


Tudor Tudor Heritage Black Bay 79730

Buyer recommends this dealer

Shipping
Item description
Communication

Buyer's comment:

First time buying from Tarrytown Jewlers. Communication was on point. Even responded back to me around 12am when I was asking questions. Would definitely buy from again and I trust them 100%.

Dealer's comment:

Great buyer, polite and courteous at 12am!!! Super fast payment. Thanks for the purchase!

Order canceled

Review by Hamod A. from on 21. May 2022


Rolex Rolex GMT-Master 16753

Buyer recommends this dealer

Communication

Buyer's comment:

Hittil veldig bra

Review by RUBIN L. from on 19. May 2022


IWC IWC Portugieser Chronograph Bucherer 1W371492

Buyer recommends this dealer

Shipping
Item description
Communication

Buyer's comment:

Tarrytown Jewelers comes well-recommended from me. I had several questions pre-purchase and they (specifically Josh) were very helpful and patient in answering them. Even during / after the purchase when the item was delivered, I still had some questions on the warranty and authentication - they were answered reasonably fast, and the item arrived in my country in < 4 days (it was stuck longer with FedEx in my country). Thank you for the lovely watch, and good service!

Dealer's comment:

Fabulous transaction, Very knowledgeable buyer, with great communication skills. A real gentleman and pleasure to work with. Thanks for the business and enjoy your purchase.

Review by IC from on 18. May 2022


Rolex Rolex Submariner 16613

Buyer recommends this dealer

Shipping
Item description
Communication

Buyer's comment:

-

Review by Jorge A. L. from on 16. May 2022


Parmigiani Fleurier Fleurier Pershing 005

Buyer recommends this dealer

Shipping
Item description
Communication

Buyer's comment:

-

Review by Jesus V. from on 16. May 2022


TAG Heuer Ladies Aquaracer

Buyer recommends this dealer

Shipping
Item description

Buyer's comment:

beautiful clock, delivery in time, really wonderful ,service, tahnkyou

Review by Stephen G. from on 16. May 2022


Tudor Black Bay Harrods

Buyer recommends this dealer

Shipping
Item description
Communication

Buyer's comment:

Fast shipping and watch was exactly as described.

Review by Christopher C. from on 09. May 2022


Rolex Date 15200

Shipping
Item description
Communication

Buyer's comment:

Before buying from Tarrytown Jewelers please consider this review. It will be factual and fair-minded. 5 stars for “shipping/packaging”: It was well packaged and doubled boxed. I would highly suggest being home when the watch is expected to be delivered. This packages requires a signature but my camera recorded the delivery guy simply leaving it at my doorstop without ringing the doorbell or knocking to see if someone was home to sign. This is not a reflection of the seller but it is worth noting if you are going to buy any item of high price ensure you are home. 2 stars for “accuracy of description of the item”: There were two major concerns here that I did address with the seller. The first is that one of the primary pictures showed the watch with box and papers. When the watch arrived all the papers were not included and the seller explained that it was a mistake including some of the papers as the original owner later asked for them back due to them containing sensitive data. I did find it odd that the original owner sold a watch and papers, Tarrytown then had time to professionally take pictures with all papers, then later the owner asked for them back and Tarrytown forgot that they listed a primary imagine containing items that they had to return. Regardless of how it all happened, a tremendous buying point for me was the advertisement that the watch came with how it was advertised. My “price offer” of the watch also was with this in consideration. So in this aspect, I paid a specific price for something that was not as advertised regardless of the reasons why. The part that gets worse is the condition of the watch being listed as “very good”. According to Chrono24, “very good” means “worn with little to no signs of wear”. When I read that description, it means to me all aspects of the watch, not some of it or parts of it, but all of it. To be as fair as possible, the viewable part of the watch is in very good condition and all parts of the watch function as they should. The problem is noted when I took off the bracelet for inspection of the serial numbers. The serial numbers are so scratched up and deteriorated from the end link scratching it, it is almost unreadable. Yes, using proper lighting and angling techniques you can make it out but it is almost eligible. This was not disclosed by the seller and once again, I submitted a “price offer” based upon how I thought the watch was and not knowing this information. Regardless of this sometimes happening to this model watch or not, it was not disclosed to me prior to purchase. 5 stars for “communication”: The seller responded in an appropriate time, normally in a day or two. Tarrytown did not offer any mediation or price adjustments to the issues I address. I feel my concerns were honest and legitimate and something most people would question. If you buy from Tarrytown please ensure you ask questions and seek clarification on any concerns you have prior to purchase. Chris

Dealer's comment:

The Buyer is correct, whenever you purchase an expensive item that is adult signature required, always make sure there is someone to sign for the package, that is the reason this website provides the tracking information. With regards to the other comments. As explained to the buyer, the original posting showed the sales receipt from when the watch was purchased from the AD in 1999. The former owner of the watch requested the return of this paperwork, as they contained his personal information. The image in the listing was unfortunately not modified to reflect this reality. While it is always nice to have all paperwork associated with a watch, this document by no means constitutes "papers", which are generally accepted by the Watch Community to mean the Rolex Warranty, which were included with the watch when sent. As far as the contention of the condition not being accurate, the case serial numbers were scratched from over 20 years of friction and contact between the end pieces and the case, which is certainly par for the course for a watch of this age, and these numbers were definitely both visible and readable, and corresponded to the numbers on the Rolex papers. We would be happy to provide an image of the case with the numbers to demonstrate this. The buyer is certainly entitled to his opinion, and we respect his attention to detail and standards, although much of the criticsm is unwarranted as explained. That said he is welcome to return the watch if he so wishes.

Review by Keith K. from on 08. May 2022


Rolex Daytona 116523

Buyer recommends this dealer

Shipping
Item description
Communication

Buyer's comment:

-

Review by Marcus C. from on 06. May 2022


Cartier Tank Francaise W51002Q3

Buyer recommends this dealer

Shipping
Item description
Communication

Buyer's comment:

It was a pleasure doing business with Josh. He was very thorough and attentive, with all my questions and requests. I purchased a beautiful Cartier Tank Francaise, which was delivered within two days. Lightin Fast. I highly recommend Tarrytown Jewelers, to all future customers. Thanks Josh, Marcus

Dealer's comment:

Thank you for a very smooth and no issues transaction. Enjoy your purchase.

Review by John V. from on 03. May 2022


Rolex Datejust Thunderbird 16264

Buyer recommends this dealer

Shipping
Item description
Communication

Buyer's comment:

Excellent communication, incredibly fast shipping and great packaging. Not to mention a fantastic watch. Can't recommend enough.

Dealer's comment:

Thanks for the compliments. Buyer was a pleasure to work with. Effivient, knowledgeable and fast paying. Thank you for your business.

Review by Matthew B. from on 02. May 2022


A. Lange & Söhne Saxonia 380.032

Buyer recommends this dealer

Shipping
Item description
Communication

Buyer's comment:

Outstanding dealer, very honest and trustworthy

Dealer's comment:

Great buyer. Fantastic to work with. Thank you for your business.

Review by Jeremy G. from on 28. April 2022


Rolex Datejust 41 116334

Buyer recommends this dealer

Shipping
Item description
Communication

Buyer's comment:

-

Review by Florian F. from on 27. April 2022


Parmigiani Fleurier Fleurier Toric Perpetual

Buyer recommends this dealer

Shipping
Item description
Communication

Buyer's comment:

Absolutely perfect! Thank you for everything

Dealer's comment:

Fabulous no issues transaction. A++ buyer. Enjoy the watch and wear in good health.

Older than 30 days

Review by Jason L. from on 25. April 2022


Rolex ...

Buyer recommends this dealer

Shipping
Item description
Communication

Buyer's comment:

Easy transaction....everything was as expected.

Dealer's comment:

Excellent buyer. Fast payment and great communication. Thank you for your business.

Review by Alexander K. from on 21. April 2022


Zenith ...

Buyer recommends this dealer

Shipping
Item description

Buyer's comment:

-

Review by Matt W. from on 19. April 2022


Vacheron Constantin ...

Buyer recommends this dealer

Shipping
Item description
Communication

Buyer's comment:

Very understanding and communicative and great inventory. Returned item but had no issues with return.

Review by Kin Yi(Tippy) L. from on 19. April 2022


Rolex ...

Buyer recommends this dealer

Shipping
Item description
Communication

Buyer's comment:

-

Review by Gregory from on 18. April 2022


Rolex ...

Buyer recommends this dealer

Shipping
Item description
Communication

Buyer's comment:

very quick in responding in all communications, shipping and packaging was excellent, the watch is in pristine condition as described. a very professional interaction, would strongly recommend.

Dealer's comment:

Excellent transaction. Super responsive buyer. Pleasure to work with. Appreciate the business. Enjoy your purchase and wear in good health.

Review by Salvador M. from on 18. April 2022


Breguet ...

Buyer recommends this dealer

Shipping
Item description

Buyer's comment:

-

Order canceled

Review by George C. from on 18. April 2022


Panerai ...

Buyer recommends this dealer

Communication

Buyer's comment:

-

Order canceled

Review by Basharat S. from on 10. April 2022


Omega ...

Buyer recommends this dealer

Communication

Buyer's comment:

-

Review by Di J. from on 07. April 2022


Patek Philippe ...

Buyer recommends this dealer

Shipping
Item description
Communication

Buyer's comment:

Nice. Really fast.

Dealer's comment:

Thank you for your business and a super smooth and first class transaction. Enjoy your new watch and wear in good health.

Order canceled

Review by Patrick W. from on 05. April 2022


Rolex ...

Buyer recommends this dealer

Communication

Buyer's comment:

Ver helpful and responsive to my inquiry. We managed to have a happy ending. Thanks

Order canceled

Review by Siew Nyii W. from on 05. April 2022


Rolex ...

Buyer recommends this dealer

Communication

Buyer's comment:

Dealer is very helpful and responsive. Highly recommended Dealer.

Review by Benjamin M. from on 05. April 2022


Jaeger-LeCoultre ...

Buyer recommends this dealer

Shipping
Item description

Buyer's comment:

Very good watch - as advertised.

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • ...
  • 6
  • 12
  • 18
  • 24
  • Next